
Thursday, 5 February 2009
Tourism and the Environment Part 2

The Ultimate Wilderness - for how long?

Krippendorf’s (1995: 308) idea that ‘tourism destroys tourism’, whereby landscapes lose their tourist value through use (or overuse) by tourists, applies nowhere more so than in wilderness where, strictly speaking, any evidence of humanity should be absent. Wilderness areas are arguably the most sensitive physical resources for tourism. A solitary tourist accessing wilderness settings may have an unacceptable physical impact thereby degrading the wilderness status of the environment. If encountered by another, the same tourist may violate wilderness experiences if solitude is an important aspect of the total experience. Physical and visual impacts, crowding and acceptable levels of social contact pose obvious wilderness management difficulties.
Antarctica as a wilderness covers 50 million km 2, including the Southern Ocean. The land mass alone is 14 million km 2, and 98% is covered with ice that on average is 2km thick (contains 90% of world's fresh water). The climate is extremely harsh with the record minimum being -89.6C.
Politically Antarctica is a neutral territory with no miltary presence other than scientific research. The Antarctic Treaty was drawn up in 1959 and ratified in 1961 and was signed by the 12 leading countries of the United Nations, the Antarctic Treaty System. In 1964 the ATS adopted the first measure to Conserve the Arctic Flora and Fauna. This was reviewed and enhanced by the Protocol on Environmental Protection in 1991 and came into force in 1998 designating Antarctica as a natural reserve.
Although commonly portrayed as the last great wilderness, Antarctica is no longer a pristine environment. At some locations, particularly around long-standing research stations, evidence of past human activity is clear. Many Antarctic stations have disused refuse tip sites, that are now the focus of clean-up efforts. Thankfully, times have changed and current waste management practices in Antarctica are now more refined With the ratification of the Madrid Protocol on Environmental Protection to the Antarctic Treaty in 1998, all countries operating in the Antarctic are now committed to comprehensive protection of the environment. The Madrid Protocol specifies that all newly generated waste should be removed from Antarctica, and member countries are even obliged to remove "old" waste unless the action of removing the waste creates a greater adverse environmental impact than leaving the waste where it is.
Tourism is now the latest threat to this environment as more visitors arrive each year and in the 1990/91 season 4,842 people visited Antarctica and this grew to 46,069 in the 2007/2008. Over 36% of the visitors are from the USA, 16% UK, 11% Germany and the remaining 37 % all from the economically developed world.Typically these toursist aer tertiary educated, well travelled and have high disposable incomes and are looking for a unique nature based experience.
TASKS:
1. Construct a Case Study on Antarctica: use the RESORCES links below to help -
(i) consider the historical development
(ii) the main attractions of Antarctica as a tourist destination
(iii) the threats increasing toursim raises for the environment and biodiversity.
2. Is wilderness tourism a viable extension of ecotoursim or is it, as some scientists describe it, 'egotourism' and a threat to wilderness regions? Discuss (10 marks)
RESOURCES
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/24629.stm
http://www.responsibletravel.com/Copy/Copy103555.htm
http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2007/apr/30/travelsenvironmentalimpact.frontpagenews
Tuesday, 3 February 2009
The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly - Ecotourism
MAKE NOTES FROM THE FOLLOWING:
- The Costs and Benefits of Ecotourism in Costa Rica
- The Impact of Ecotoursim in Costa Rica
- Forest Conservation in Costa Rica
- Bowen & Pallister pp296-299 (A2 Textbook)
TASK: Complete the following for the 23 February 2009
GGA5 Synoptic Essay
Tourism in any environment is likely to generate as many costs as benefits. Discuss this view with reference to areas you have studied. (30)
Thursday, 8 January 2009
Tourism and the Environment PART 1
Much depends upon the nature of the tourist and the sttle/type of tourism.
Increased tourist flow can cause pressure on the environment which results in further problems and can lead to conflict.
TASK 1 Make notes on the IMPACTS OF TOURISM from this link
http://www.gdrc.org/uem/eco-tour/envi/one.html
National Parks in England and Wales - an example of conflict managed -
ASPECTS OF GREEN TOURISM
National Parks are often cited as examples of how tourism and the environment can be managed together. An estimated 110 million people visit the national parks of England and Wales each year. Recreation and tourism bring visitors and funds into the parks, to sustain their conservation efforts and support the local population through jobs and businesses. These visitors also bring problems, such as erosion and traffic congestion, and conflicts over the use of the parks' resources. The national funding offered to National Park Authorities is partly in recognition of the extra difficulties created in dealing with these conflicts.
Each park is operated by its own National Park Authority, with two 'statutory purposes'.
1. to conserve and enhance the natural beauty, wildlife and cultural heritage of the area, and
2. to promote opportunities for the understanding and enjoyment of the park's special qualities by the public.
These purposes can conflict: in such cases, under the 'Sandford Principle', conservation normally comes first. This principle was given statutory force by section 62 of the Environment Act 1995. In pursuing these purposes, National Park Authorities also have a duty to foster the social and economic well-being of their local communities.
Click on the image for detailed information about the new Management Strategy for the Yorkshire Dales.
TASK 2:
i)Give reasons why MAIN MANAGEMENT POLICIES and STEWARDSHIP SCHEMES employed in the Yorkshire Dales National Park are essential in managing the impact of tourism.
ii) Evaluate the success of the main policies
You also need to download the PDF documents on Tourism in the Yorkshire Dales from the Document Library (click here)
TASK 3: Comment on the likely differences and causes of conflict between valley floor and fell top tourism in two named areas of the Yorkshire Dales.
The following document gives a detailed insight into the guiding principles of Mountain Tourism.
Wednesday, 31 December 2008
Responsible Tourism
Wednesday, 26 November 2008
Tourism as a Development Strategy

Over the last few decades several countries have looked towards tourism as a means of
promoting development and economic growth. Tourism has grown to become the world’s
second largest industry, directly accounting for 3.8 percent of global GDP in 2005 according to
the World Travel and Tourism Council (WTTC). Experiences from various countries have shown
that tourism can have significant effects, both positive and negative, on an economy. It has
been noted that the very process of developing tourism and the consequences of this
development imposes social, cultural and environmental costs for the country.
Use 'Population, Resources and Development' by Jane Chrispen and Francis Jegede.
Read 10.3 The Role of tourism in development on page 157.
Make notes on 'The Core-periphery enclave model' from page 158.
Read 'The development of tourism in Goa' on pages 159-161.
Make notes on 'The development of tourism in Goa' on pages 159-161.
Answer questions 7, 8 and 9 on page 161.
Read 'Tourism and development in The Gambia' pages 164 and 165.
Answer questions 13, 14 and 15 on page 165.
Schott's Almanac of New Tourism
Britons spurning foreign holidays as economy dips Environment guardian.co.uk
BBC NEWS Asia-Pacific Tourism slow as Olympics approach
Goodbye cheap flights, welcome back real travel... Travelog guardian.co.uk
BBC NEWS UK Magazine Benidorm - the new face of eco-tourism
Benidorm paints itself green Travel guardian.co.uk
BBC NEWS Europe Icy mood grips Kosovo ski resort
The True Meaning Of Tourist Trap (washingtonpost.com)
The tourist trap Society The Guardian